The off-season was supposed to be a time for rest. For Carlos Alcaraz, it has instead become a period of reflection and rising speculation. With opinions sharply divided on whether he should bring in a new coach, the Spaniard’s next step has turned into one of the most intriguing questions heading toward the 2026 ATP season.

It all started with Juan Carlos Ferrero’s departure from his team. Ferrero had been the steady hand behind Alcaraz’s meteoric rise. From a wide-eyed teenager with electric speed to a Grand Slam champion capable of humbling legends, their partnership felt almost sacred. Under him, Alcaraz won six Grand Slams and 8 ATP Masters 1000 titles. Ferrero wasn’t just a coach; he was a mentor, a buffer from the noise, and a compass in moments of chaos. So when whispers of a split surfaced, the tennis world did what it always does - picked sides.

On one side of the debate sits former American pro Steve Johnson, speaking with the conviction of someone who believes change is inevitable at the very top. “I think so. 100% he brings somebody in. My gut tells me somebody like [Carlos] Moya or [David] Ferrer. We have talked about this a lot. Does coaching really matter? At this stage, maybe it’s not so important for Carlos. But getting to where he did, that was amazing from Juan Carlos Ferrero and what they did together.”

But across the net of opinions, Daria Saville offered a perspective shaped by life on tour rather than theory. She claimed, “I don’t actually think he’s going to be hiring anyone, anytime soon, because he’s got an established team. He’s had Samuel Lopez in his corner…” She even admitted that she felt that Carlos Alcaraz might just get reunited with Juan Carlos Ferrero later on. Her husband, Luke Saville, agreed with her, as he also felt that Alcaraz won’t make any real changes to his team before the 2026 AO.

For now, the tennis world remains divided. One camp sees an inevitable new face in the coach’s box, a fresh voice to challenge and refine a generational talent. The other sees patience, continuity, and a young superstar comfortable enough in his own skin to pause before making his next move. But what really led to this split?

As per a source close to Ferrero, revealed to CLAY, “What happened is very simple. The contract was annual. The 2025 contract ended at the end of November, and they waited until Saturday the 13th of this month to present a new one and until Monday the 15th at the first hour to sign it. Juan Carlos did not accept it, and they did not want to make any changes.”

Several reports also claimed that Juan Carlos Ferrero’s relationship with Carlos Alcaraz’s father had also deteriorated in ‌recent times. Could this be another possible reason behind their split? Because we saw Ferrero clearly mentioned that “I would have liked to continue” in his farewell message.

In the middle of this sudden chaos before entering the 2026 season, Carlos Alcaraz has kept his cards close. And in doing so, he reminded everyone once again that sometimes, the loudest debates are happening everywhere - except inside the player’s own mind. Let’s check out some more reactions from tennis bigwigs about Alcaraz’s possible new coach.

Which are the names popping up as a possible replacement for Ferrero in Carlos Alcaraz’s team?

Replacing Juan Carlos Ferrero in Carlos Alcaraz’s team won’t be an easy task. But there are still a few names roaming around in the tennis world, and let me tell you that these names aren’t just coaches - they’re symbols of Spanish tennis itself. How about Alcaraz hiring his idol, Rafael Nadal, to take up the new role?

Well, this question has been brought up on several occasions ever since the announcement of his split with Ferrero. But if we take a look at an expert’s take on these speculations, according to Greg Rusedski, “I just don’t think Rafael Nadal is at a time in his life when he wants to get back on the tour and travel every week. Nadal has two young children, and he seems to be enjoying his retirement, so I just don’t see him giving everything up to go back on the road with Alcaraz.”

Nadal has publicly backed Carlos Alcaraz on multiple occasions, praising not just his game but also his character. To many fans and former players, that connection feels like destiny waiting for the right moment. But romance doesn’t always translate into reality.

Coming to the other namedrop, according to Brad Gilbert, Alcaraz’s new coach could be Rafael Nadal’s former coach, Carlos Moya. In fact, he also kept David Ferrer in the list of possible replacements for Ferrero.

Just when everyone was busy picking names, Paul McNamee reminded the tennis world that Swiss legend Roger Federer won several Grand Slam titles without a coach. He feels Carlos Alcaraz is an extremely talented player, and hence, there shouldn’t be any concern if he fails to find a replacement for Ferrero. Although some reports suggest that Samuel Lopez could possibly take over the role from Ferrero and guide Alcaraz in the early phase of 2026. Who do you think could be a good replacement for someone like Juan Carlos Ferrero?

Written by

Sayantan Roy

Sayantan Roy is a seasoned tennis journalist at EssentiallyTennis. He brings a deep tactical understanding to his coverage, breaking down head-to-head records, match dynamics, and on-court strategies with precision. For more than two years, Sayantan has been a key member of the Live Events desk, delivering real-time insights and data-backed predictions for the platform’s Matchday Preview section. His analytical approach has sparked editorial debates and drawn recognition from respected tennis voices, including commentator and analyst Olly_Tennis. Combining his experience in writing with a passion for insightful sports journalism, Sayantan’s work serves as a trusted reference point for tennis fans around the world.

Know more