Rafael Nadal has finally addressed the storm sparked by Patrick Mouratoglou’s recent comments comparing the iconic Big Three era with the current dominance of Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner. The Spanish legend, known for rarely engaging in off-court debates, made his stance clear after the French coach suggested that Novak Djokovic’s Australian Open semifinal victory over Sinner did not prove that the Big Three were superior to the new generation.

Mouratoglou, who previously coached Serena Williams and Naomi Osaka, argued that drawing long-term conclusions from a single match was misguided. Sharing his views on Instagram, the Frenchman wrote, “Thinking that Alcaraz and Sinner aren’t better than the Big Three just because Novak beat Sinner at the Australian Open is a short-term view. One match never tells the whole story. Perspective matters!” Nadal initially reacted with a string of emojis - “🤭🫣🤣🤣🤣” - before deleting the comment, triggering widespread speculation and debate within the tennis world.

Addressing the controversy during the presentation of a charity golf tournament at Madrid’s Club de Campo, Rafael Nadal downplayed the drama surrounding his reaction and subsequent deletion. “I don’t see the controversy. I don’t want to create controversy,” Nadal explained. He then clarified his disagreement with Mouratoglou’s analysis, adding, “The point is that that gentleman’s analysis is wrong, because it’s like comparing today’s Messi with the Messi who played for Barça, or today’s Cristiano Ronaldo with the one who played for Real Madrid. That’s simply my point of view.”

Coming back to the Frenchman's interesting comments in recent times. Expanding on his argument in that previous instance, Patrick Mouratoglou stated, “Novak is not a better tennis player than Sinner, but he’s the biggest competitor in history, and he was better than Jannik Sinner in that match.” While acknowledging Djokovic’s competitive greatness, the coach maintained that peak performance levels across generations cannot be directly compared.

The debate quickly drew reactions from other prominent figures in the tennis community. Serena Williams’ childhood coach Rick Macci weighed in via X (formerly Twitter), responding to Mouratoglou’s continued remarks. “Asked again in a podcast about Mouratoglou doubling down and chirping that Novak does nothing outstanding,” Macci wrote. “Everything in life is in the eye of the beholder. The Joker does everything outstanding and more. What you may see is very different than Rick Macci.”

Despite being more than a decade older than most of today’s top 10 players, Djokovic continues to challenge and defeat the sport’s brightest young stars, including Alcaraz and Sinner. That longevity and consistency have strengthened the argument of those who believe the Big Three’s legacy remains unmatched.

Even German legend Boris Becker entered the conversation, bluntly dismissing Mouratoglou’s view. “Patrick, I think you’re alone with your opinion!” Becker posted on X. Mouratoglou responded sharply, saying, “I never made an opinion based on what people think, but out of my own opinion. Only dead fish swim with the stream.”

More recently, Becker appeared to back Nadal’s stance as well, sharing a post featuring the Spaniard’s reaction with the caption, “Word, Rafa.” 

Rafael Nadal, meanwhile, remained composed in his interview, reiterating that generational greatness should be judged within its own context rather than through direct comparisons - a subtle but firm reminder of why the Big Three era continues to command such reverence in tennis history. What else did the Spaniard say in his interview, though?

Rafael Nadal showers praise on Novak Djokovic and Carlos Alcaraz

Rafael Nadal may have stepped away from professional tennis, but his voice continues to carry immense weight in the sport. The Spanish icon recently opened up about Novak Djokovic and Carlos Alcaraz, offering heartfelt praise for both stars while urging fans to simply appreciate what they bring to the game.

“In the end, everyone has their own career, and I never said that some are better than others. Each person's career will show who has been better, and they are all great ambassadors for our sport,” Nadal said. “I think we should be happy to have someone like Novak, who is still at the top after so many years on the circuit. Having Carlos is a blessing, because he is a great player who represents us all over the world, and on top of that, he is taking tennis to an incredible level. I think we can only enjoy and appreciate it, that's all.”

Carlos Alcaraz’s dominance has become one of the defining narratives of modern tennis. While many still refer to him as the sport’s “next big thing,” Nadal strongly disagrees with that label. In his eyes, Alcaraz is no longer a rising prospect - he is already an established legend.

The numbers support that claim. In 2025 alone, Alcaraz lifted eight tour-level trophies, including Masters 1000 titles in Monte Carlo, Rome, and Cincinnati. He also added two Grand Slam crowns to his resume, triumphing at Roland Garros and the US Open.

This season, the Spaniard achieved what had previously eluded him - conquering the Australian Open. In a blockbuster final, Alcaraz defeated Novak Djokovic in four sets, handing the Serbian his first-ever loss in a Melbourne final and capturing his seventh major title. The victory also made him the youngest player in the Open Era to complete a career Grand Slam, surpassing Rafael Nadal’s previous record, while pushing his overall tour tally to 25 titles.

Now embracing what he describes as “tennis fan” mode following his retirement, Nadal reflected on watching the tour from the sidelines. “It feels calmer and without any strange feelings because my time here ended the way it was meant to. I extended my career longer than I ever imagined, and now I'm completely happy to see my colleagues succeed, and in a way, I also enjoy their success.”

As for Djokovic’s pursuit of a record-extending 25th Grand Slam title, Nadal offered a measured yet respectful take. “It’s done; I don't think we need to analyze tennis based on who wins. He had an opportunity in Melbourne, and at this stage of his career, to be honest, he doesn't have that many left, and I think what he's achieving is admirable.”

In typical Rafael Nadal fashion, the Spaniard avoided fueling comparisons or debates. Instead, he chose admiration over rivalry, celebrating Djokovic’s longevity and Alcaraz’s brilliance while reminding the tennis world that it is witnessing a rare and remarkable era worth savoring.

Written by

Sayantan Roy

Sayantan Roy is a seasoned tennis journalist at EssentiallyTennis. He brings a deep tactical understanding to his coverage, breaking down head-to-head records, match dynamics, and on-court strategies with precision. For more than two years, Sayantan has been a key member of the Live Events desk, delivering real-time insights and data-backed predictions for the platform’s Matchday Preview section. His analytical approach has sparked editorial debates and drawn recognition from respected tennis voices, including commentator and analyst Olly_Tennis. Combining his experience in writing with a passion for insightful sports journalism, Sayantan’s work serves as a trusted reference point for tennis fans around the world.

Know more